Second Judge Blocks Trump's Triumphal Arch, Calling It a "Rushed Job"

Second Judge Blocks Trump's Triumphal Arch, Calling It a "Rushed Job"
Illustrative image

A federal judge on Friday blocked construction of President Donald Trump's proposed triumphal arch, saying it was a "rushed job" that lacked a legal basis — the second judge this week to halt the project.

During a court hearing in Alexandria, Virginia, US District Judge Leonie Brinkema said she would issue a preliminary injunction indefinitely blocking the proposed 250-foot arch between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery from moving forward while she hears a legal challenge brought by Virginia's Arlington County, CNN reported.

Brinkema, an appointee of President Bill Clinton, said there were multiple defects in the federal government's analysis of the economic and environmental impact of the project, including an inadequate explanation of how it will affect nearby Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport.

"That just hasn't been done in the case because it's been such a rushed job," the judge said, according to CNN.

"I don't see any way" the government wins

Brinkema went further than simply pausing construction. She suggested Arlington County is likely to prevail in the case, saying she did not see "any way" the government could ultimately win on the merits of its legal arguments, and that federal administrative law "has been significantly violated" in the government's efforts to build the monument, Bloomberg Law reported.

The judge also pointed to what she described as defects in the government's impact analysis, including the effect of having construction cranes as high as 320 feet in the air while the arch is built.

She reiterated that the project lacks congressional approval, which the Trump administration has not sought. The administration argues the arch is covered by a 1925 law authorising a pair of much shorter columns at the same location, which were never built. Both judges who have ruled on the project have frowned upon that argument. "It hurts your credibility with the court by focusing on that," Brinkema told the government's lawyers, according to NPR.

A Justice Department spokesperson, Matthew Nies, told NPR the department will appeal the decision immediately.

A second setback in three days

Brinkema is the second judge to rule against the arch this week. On Wednesday, US District Judge Tanya Chutkan in Washington, D.C., extended a temporary restraining order preventing the Trump administration from breaking ground through December 3 while she considers the underlying legal arguments. Chutkan, an appointee of President Barack Obama, initially blocked construction on November 5, shortly after the National Capital Planning Commission gave the arch its final approval in an 8-4 vote, despite dozens of witnesses who opposed it.

Friday's injunction goes further: unlike Chutkan's order, it has no specified expiration date and blocks construction for the duration of Arlington County's case.

The 250-foot arch would be built in Memorial Circle, which is part of Washington, D.C., but sits on the Virginia side of the Potomac River, a short distance from Arlington National Cemetery and Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport.

Arlington's objections

Arlington County, which sued over the project in October, argues the arch would disrupt historic sightlines between Arlington National Cemetery and Washington's National Mall and pose logistical challenges for the roughly 24 to 27 funerals the cemetery holds every weekday. The county also has concerns about air and road traffic, saying construction-related delays could cause more accidents and disrupt emergency vehicles far beyond the traffic circle.

The plaintiffs, like many critics of the arch, accused the Trump administration of rushing through federally mandated environmental reviews and failing to consider alternatives. The National Park Service has defended the federal review process — which ended in approval earlier this month — and said building the arch somewhere else would defeat its purpose.

"The County brings this lawsuit to halt the agency's feverish pace toward construction of the Arch and to ensure that the 'hard look' mandated by [the National Environmental Policy Act] is completed before the agency commences disruptive and harmful ground-disturbing activities," the county argued in its filing.

Democracy Forward, the nonprofit representing Arlington County, welcomed the ruling. "We are pleased that the court has recognized the irreparable harm that will come to people who live and work in Arlington and stopped the massive vanity project while our case is heard and considered by the court," the group said in a statement shared with NPR.

The case is County Board of Arlington County, Virginia v. National Park Service, in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia.

Latest development

Friday's ruling is the latest setback to Trump's efforts to reshape Washington's historic buildings and spaces. The arch is one of several of the president's Washington projects to face legal challenges, and with two federal judges now blocking construction — one indefinitely — the project faces months of delay even before the underlying legal questions are resolved.

Sources

Read more: Judge Rules Agriculture Secretary Rollins's Religious Mass Emails to Staff Unconstitutional

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Senate Blocks Iran War Powers Resolution in 48–51 Vote, Backing Trump

Canadian Home Sales Down 10.6% From a Year Ago in October, CREA Reports

Mary Peltola Flips Alaska Senate Seat, Defeating Dan Sullivan